Showing posts with label essays. Show all posts
Showing posts with label essays. Show all posts

Friday, December 22, 2006

The Character of HAL 9000

This is the third installment of a multi-part series in which I post the best college papers ever written in the entire history of the universe... by me. Voila!

I.
Introduction/Disclaimer

The difficulties that arise from examining the “character” of HAL 9000, or any other element of the narrative in Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey, are hazardous and abundant. 2001 is a film whose plot is constructed in a deliberately opaque manner, defying most, if not all, of the classical Hollywood conventions. Temporally, it “spans infinity rather than days or years”; spatially, it “embodies a kind of ultimate cinematic universe” without the assurances of a “normal perspective”; in short, it is a “frontal assault on the traditional conventions of Hollywood filmmaking” (Nelson 110). Out of 160 minutes of film, only 40 minutes of footage contain dialogue, most of which does little to further the audience’s understanding of the story (Fry 333). Kubrick himself stated that he “intended the film to be an intensely subjective experience that reaches the viewer at an inner level of consciousness, just as music does; to ‘explain’ a Beethoven symphony would be to emasculate it by erecting an artificial barrier between conception and appreciation” (Fry 333). Basically, Kubrick never meant for this story to be put into words, never meant it to be explained, verbalized, or articulated; rather, he meant it to be experienced, seen visually and heard musically, and only inwardly appreciated.

Indeed, this poses a problem in trying to pin down anything coherent about a purposefully enigmatic narrative in twelve pages, but despite this challenge, an attempt will be made to elucidate the narrative function of the HAL 9000 character.

II. Introduction/Thesis

Philosophers, scientists, theists, and atheists throughout human history have spent their entire lives musing on the eternal question, “Why?” Why man? Why earth? Why the universe? Why anything? It is this self-consciousness, perhaps, that separates us from any other living thing known to mankind -- it is, perhaps, the only thing that makes us special. If this is true, then what does one make of an artificially created conscious, invented and molded by the hands of man, HAL 9000? Most viewers of the film agree that HAL is more than just an action prop with an electronic voice, more than just a machine; he (not it) is a full-fledged character in the narrative. But as the pinnacle of man’s creativity and technological achievement, what kind of character is he? How human is he? Is he a hero or villain?

On a smaller, more literal level, HAL is unquestionably human, and perhaps a tragic villain in the vein of Mary Shelley’s monster in Frankenstein. However, as a symbol for what technology means in relation to man, and as the pinnacle of what technology can achieve, a tool that replicates all the complexities of the human mind, HAL 9000 is a character that transcends the question of humanity and the paradigm of good and evil to achieve a more cosmically significant status in the narrative, not as a representation of man’s follies, but as simply another stepping stone to walk over in man’s evolution.

III. HAL’s Humanity

Even before HAL 9000 ever enters the narrative, the notion of latent humanity being buried or constructed within man’s technological creations is explored. Various images or objects suggest the idea that technology, something most people view as cold, mechanical, and inhuman, is actually a very human, even organic thing.

During the “Dawn of Man” section, in fact, the first tool, the first technological idea for man, is a bone, part of something that used to be alive. Bones are something very vital to higher life forms such as mammals, and the fact that the first ape-man uses this object that was once alive as a tool, as a technology, inextricably ties life and technology together, from technology’s very birth onward. The notion that technology is also tied to death, by way of violence, is also suggested by the use of a dead bone from a dead animal, but this idea will be explored more thoroughly later in the paper.

This idea doesn’t die when the technologies become more complex, as the famous match cut that brings us from bone to space ship suggests. Ships float through space elegantly, enhanced by the classical music soundtrack, and their graceful movements seem to have a life of their own. The spaceships movements have been described by others as anywhere from “ballet” to “a cosmic, coital dance,” and regardless of one’s interpretation, they are all human descriptions, and certainly not simple mechanical motions (Verniere 2). One particular spaceship, in fact, is a round, planet-like sphere, which we see descending into a station; it looks exactly like a human head, complete with lights for eyes. Clearly in this shot, the face of technology is human.

When the film reaches the “Jupiter Mission” section, and we are introduced to HAL 9000 for the first time, we see just exactly how human that face is. The face is actually just one big red luminous circle, like an unblinking eye that watches everything. HAL’s “eye” seems almost more human than the human crew’s eyes; the three in hibernation are virtually frozen dead bodies that don’t even get to participate in the distinctly human activity of dreaming, and the two conscious ones, Dave Bowman and Frank Poole, have extremely expressionless, blank, robotic faces, with dull eyes that do not shine with nearly as much life and vitality as HAL’s red light.

During a BBC interview with the two astronauts, much is revealed about how human HAL actually is. We are told by the interviewer, “The crew of Discovery 1 consists of five men and one of the latest generation of the HAL 9000 computers,” and it is interesting that he is even considered a component of the crew, normally understood to be a human grouping; indeed, he is more part of the “crew” of the ship than any one human, as he runs every aspect of ship operations. One particular shot from the interview frames the two astronauts side by side, with HAL right in the middle between them, as if he were not just part of the crew, but captain of the crew. In fact, it is interesting that he is even referred to as “he” at all, instead of “it.” HAL’s humanity is so inherently intuitive, that it is basically automatic to assume to call him a “he,” and not once is he ever referred to as “it.” Even when you call him by his name, you are supposed to say “Hal,” like the human name, and not say the letters “H-A-L.”

Granted, the question arises as to whether HAL can actually feel real human emotions, if he indeed is actually a replication, not just a synthetic mimicry, of the human brain. However, even in the content and manner in which HAL speaks, there seems to be a whole well full of motivations derived from truly human emotions. He states, “I enjoy working with people,” a response grounded by emotion (“enjoy”) rather than logic or mechanics. After Frank views a birthday message from his family, HAL chimes in with a, “Happy birthday, Frank,” which seems to come out of nowhere, completely unmotivated, and therefore unusually genuine. When HAL tries to persuade Dave that there’s nothing wrong, even after HAL has murdered Frank, he tries to appeal to Dave on a basic human level, citing distinctly human traits when he says, “I’ve still got the greatest enthusiasm and confidence in the mission.” Also, it’s noteworthy that he says “still got,” as if he’s lost everything else -- the logic, the computational abilities, the rationality -- and all that’s left deep down, at his core, is his inherent humanity, his “enthusiasm and confidence.” Even if phrases like that are just well-calculated moves to get Dave to stop his attempt at dismantling him, they reveal a deep, urgent need for self preservation that goes beyond the programmed parameters of completing this mission.

Finally, if HAL’s positive attributes do not point to his humanity, then the manner in which he contrasts with “real humans” certainly does. The “banality of Bowman and Poole… makes it possible for HAL… to appear… ‘more human than human’” (Verniere 3). HAL’s closest human analog would be Mission Control based on earth, and the difference between them is overt. Although Mission Control is a human speaking to Dave and Frank, the voice is filtered through radio technology, and sounds much flatter, thinner, and more electrical than HAL’s voice, which has an enveloping, deeply resonant tone. The content of their speech also differs. HAL speaks like a normal human being as he “gives counsel, shows curiosity, awards praise” (Nelson 186). Mission Control speaks in “Technish” that sounds infinitely more like the speech of a computer or machine: “X-ray-Delta-One, this is Mission Control, roger your two-zero-one-three… Roger your plan to go E-V-A and replace Alpha-Echo-three-five unit prior to failure” (Nelson 318).

IV. HAL as Tragic Villain

If HAL is indeed established to be, if not downright human, then virtually human, what kind of character does he have? What sort of human is he? The most common and immediate reaction is that he is an evil, intelligent, calculating villain. The American Film Institute listed him as the #13 villain in their “100 Years… 100 Heroes and Villains” best-of list in 2003. His voice has been described as “bland, neutral, reassuring,” but also “ambiguous, sinister, untrustworthy” (Walker 185). His actions, strictly speaking, are certainly heinous, as he murders Frank Poole in cold blood, as well as the helpless, hibernating crew members, before intentionally leaving Dave outside the ship to die. However, is this distinction so easy? Certainly, HAL’s actions are unforgivable in a sense, but there are complexities to the straight-villain claim that texture HAL’s character as more of the tragic villain type than the purely evil villain type.

First and foremost, HAL was created by man and given the gift of some form of intelligence, and in fact, consciousness. In this sense, he is a pretty clear descendent of the Frankensteinian monsters of which Mary Shelley first gave seminal vision (Kozlovic 347). These types of villains are indelibly tragic, as they were created without ever asking to be created, and always with some sort of fatal flaw that seems like a gross oversight on the part of the creator that causes the monster to suffer in some unjust way. This notion goes as far back as God’s creation of Adam only to have him expelled from Eden, as explored by John Milton in Paradise Lost, and thus suggests something inherently human about these tragic Frankensteinian monsters.

HAL’s tragic flaw, in a sense, is that he is too human. The programmers who created him did too good of a job in turning this machine into a man, full of human flaws, especially hubris. The interviewer remarks that he can detect a small bit of pride, even arrogance, in HAL’s proclamations of the 9000 series computers’ infallibility. It has been said that “HAL’s biggest crime” was not his “murderous deeds,” but his “conceit” with “claims like, ‘No 9000 computer has ever made a mistake.’ This is more than just arrogant, more than just false; it is the antithesis of realism” (Kozlovic 358). Indeed, it is this hubris that drives him to commit his villainous murders, either to cover up the possible mistake he made about the faulty part, or as a consequence of his doubts and suspicions about the mission, in which case, his hubris extends to the idea that he, as the most powerful and knowledgeable component of the mission, is above the mission. And the tragedy of that is that this was the way he was created; he was designed to be that powerful and that knowledgeable, that perfect, and in an imperfect world, this was the most cruel thing man ever did to machine -- to give it consciousness without the natural human limitations we have that rein in our arrogances every day. Another take on this idea states that “once programmed to be ‘human,’ HAL loses the machine purity that, no doubt, his Earth twin still possesses. He becomes imbued with a consciousness of his own autonomy and denies his function as a tool,” thereby compromising his “infallibility as a machine and benevolence as a deity” (Nelson 128).

The camera also provides viewers with more subjective viewpoints that underline a certain amount of empathy for HAL. The first shot of HAL we see shows the red circular eye apparently watching Poole shadowboxing around the ship. HAL’s electronic gaze, as it reflects the moving, exercising body of Poole, gives the impression that HAL is jealous of Poole’s movement, his body, his physical manifestation. HAL is only the brain and central nervous system of the ship, an electronic, digital manifestation with no body whatsoever. This, too, was part of his design, fairly or unfairly, and may have mixed dangerously with his arrogance. In any case, the viewer sees both Poole’s limitless potential for movement and action reflected in the glassy eye of HAL’s digitally tied down brain, a mind held prisoner within motionless, muscle-less circuit boards, and can feel a small bit of empathy for this brilliant, intelligent, trapped mind. In fact, “many of the images of Bowman and Poole at work are subjective camera shots from HAL’s various vantage points throughout the spaceship” (Rasmussen 83). When Dave and Frank plot to disconnect HAL, Kubrick

frames the two astronauts, facing each other, inside the oval window of a space pod, where they have retreated so as to discuss HAL’s irrational behavior without, they believe, having the computer overhear them. We see their lips move silently behind the armored glass. The shot is from HAL’s point of view; and we realize the computer is lip-reading Bowman and Poole! (Walker 187)

Knowing that they are discussing what more or less comes down to HAL’s murder, the camera pans back and forth between Dave and Frank’s lips in a panicked motion, indicating HAL’s fear of being disconnected. These point of view shots from HAL’s electronic eyes are what some have called “his distorted, subjective point of view” (Nelson 127). Thus, HAL’s pre-emptive murders are a product of survival instincts and a desire for self-preservation. Indeed, when he wields the pod to cut Frank’s oxygen tube and kill him, it becomes like “his bone club, wielded against the creator who threatens his existence” (Rasmussen 89). HAL can only be blamed insofar as his creators can be blamed for his violent acts. His limitations are man’s limitations, and thus, there must be a certain level of empathy for HAL’s confusions and flaws.

When HAL is finally being dismantled, he reveals eerily human traits. His pleas for Dave to stop are chilling and pathetic as he delivers in monotone, “Stop, Dave. I’m afraid. I’m afraid, Dave.” He keeps going back to feelings and emotions, even as those programmed features are supposedly being removed one by one by Dave: “My mind is going. I can feel it. I can feel it. My mind is going. There is no question about it. I can feel it. I can feel it. I can feel it. I’m a… fraid.” He then does a very human thing near death, which is to revert back to his own infancy, in a moment much like his entire life flashing before his eyes, as he introduces himself and asks if Dave would like to hear a song his instructor taught him when he first became operational. In a sign of shared empathy or humanity, Dave significantly speaks for the first time during this gruesome operation, telling HAL to sing the song, as if to distract HAL from the pain of death. This moment is so poignant, and points to even Dave’s recognition of his own sympathy for HAL, that HAL’s death, despite his own deeds, becomes that of a truly tragic villain.

V. HAL Beyond the Infinite

Beyond just being a pivotal character in the narrative, whether human or non-human, tragic or evil, HAL also transcends these common paradigms of character to play a more cosmically important role as the stepping stone of man from dawn to maturity. This take on HAL acknowledges what is impossible to ignore: that 2001 as a whole is a film that begins before time, reveals the universe and even existence itself coming into existence, and then relates the history of man’s evolutionary development, from ape-man to some future transcendent stage as a Star Child. HAL merely represents the final step in this transformative process.

To begin with, critics commonly structure the film into four major sections, three of them subtitled by Kubrick:

  1. The Dawn of Man
    • A primeval ape man makes a breakthrough - becoming endowed with intelligence after experiencing a mysterious black monolith
  2. The lunar journey in the year 2000 (untitled)
    • Eons later, a similar monolith is discovered on the lunar surface in the 21st century, sending its signals to Jupiter
  3. Jupiter Mission, 18 Months Later
    • A futuristic, 18-month journey to Jupiter, featuring HAL 9000
  4. Jupiter and Beyond the Infinite
    • A mystical experience in another time and dimension (Dirks)

The separation between “The Dawn of Man” section and the untitled lunar journey is often thought to be obvious, as it is marked by the famous match cut from bone to spaceship, a cut that spans eons of time and countless technological improvements and discoveries. When the audience sees the cut, the “illusion of progress encourages us to accept this shift with little resistance,” but it is more interesting (and more correct) to assume that Kubrick chose to not separate the lunar journey segment with a subtitle for a reason, that it should actually be included as a continuation of “The Dawn of Man” (Castle). The evidence for this view is strong, as this longer dawn is marked by “two signposts” on the perimeter:

the monoliths. One has been placed in the ape’s encampment; the other, buried on the moon. Man’s ‘dawn’ has occurred not in a single bound to a smarter ape but within the whole space of four million years. This time marks a prelude to the journey to Jupiter, which will change man’s relation to the technological universe (Castle).

In other words, the entire first section introduces man as he develops pathetically through the utilization of technology, tied inextricably to the capacity for violence. The entire second section, centered around HAL, is the turning point, in which the culmination and pinnacle of what technology can achieve ultimately proves to be nothing more than a bigger, fancier expression of man’s capacity for technologically enabled violence. It is the last, final moment of apes bludgeoning themselves with levers, after which, in the third and final act, man is reborn into a higher form, beyond technology, and therefore, optimistically, beyond violence.

Exploring this grand, beginning-of-time-until-the-end-of-man narrative structure of the film would involve several papers’ worth of ideas, so this paper will focus on the middle section, HAL’s section, as a transitional “birthing period” for the emergence of this “new” man. This perspective simply underlines the point that HAL is not a mere character in this story, but, as the culmination of current man’s limitations vis-à-vis his dependence on technology vis-à-vis expressions of violence, overcoming and moving beyond HAL is an evolutionary step in the process of reaching the Star Child.

Images involving the process of birth abound in this section. The very first shot is of the Discovery 1 spaceship, which is shaped very much like a sperm cell, with a large head in front and a long, thin tail with rocket boosters in the back powering the ship’s movement. Indeed, this mission is very much like a sperm swimming through space, looking for a cosmic ovum to conceive a “new man” with. At this point, HAL is working on the ship in conjunction with, not against, this goal.

However, it is when HAL turns on humans that he actually truly propels them forward, pushing Dave to the next level, forcing him to overcome the still dawning man’s vestigial reliance on technology, to transcend that limiting human trait and evolve into a superior state. Humans “retain more immature traits longer than any other vertebrate on the planet” (Westfahl 103), and technology has simply been one of those immature traits that have endured over man’s four billion year long dawning, and now must be shed on the way to greater biological glory.

The sex-and-birth-related imagery continues to enhance the showdown between Dave and HAL, between man and his own technology. When Dave finds himself inside a pod, without a space helmet, locked outside of the spaceship by HAL, there seems to be no escape, and HAL seems to have triumphed in stifling -- suffocating -- man’s evolution. However, in a triumph of distinctly human ingenuity over mechanical logic, Dave forces his own re-entry into Discovery 1 with explosive bolts from his little pod, bolts which “were originally designed to help astronauts escape out of a malfunctioning pod, not into a malfunctioning Discovery” (Rasmussen 96). Dave sets the emergency bolts ready to explode the door open, and kneels down in front of it, crouching in a fetal-like position before shutting his eyes, looking for all the world like a baby preparing to enter the birth canal. The shots of his forced re-entry are more like a rape. His body bursts into the blood red air chamber, a womb, along with a cloud of white, semen-like smoke. After this moment, a reborn Dave stalks through the ship towards the room that houses HAL’s brain, “tracked by a hand-held camera attuned to his erratic breathing,” the film now fully taking on an unstable, but human perspective, the perspective of the victor. Before this, the camera moved in controlled, mechanical pans or simply remained stationary, implicitly assuming the perspective of a machine-dominated world. This victory, then, becomes a validation of man over machine, anointing and signaling his rebirth as he enters HAL’s Logic Memory Center and unscrews his brain-cards, and overtaking control.

HAL’s “death” climaxes the film’s treatment of humanity as Tool-Maker and provides a necessary step toward the symbolic implications of […] the birth of the Star Child. Visually, […] the use of subjective camera devices and disorienting angles signifies the presence of an important internal struggle. Images of circles and corridors convert the interior of Discovery into a well-lit womb of death where hibernators are aborted, and one character, from the darkness of space, gains re-entry to destroy the tool […] and begin a new evolutionary cycle” (Nelson 123).

HAL, for all his humanity or inhumanity, for all his tragedy or evil, was thus a necessity, because “HAL’s ‘humanity’ (his madness) forces Bowman to rediscover his own,” ultimately “[stimulating] growth” (Nelson 142). Put another way, technology’s flaws of inherent violence thus force man to rediscover a new humanity, and a new path of higher consciousness.

VI. Conclusion

Any method of reading Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey becomes reductive or problematic in some way. As one critic put it, “Screwing with audiences’ heads was Stanley Kubrick’s favorite hobby outside of chess” and this film “remains Kubrick’s crowning, confounding achievement” (Verniere 1). HAL himself will always remain a mysterious black box filled with questions, questions about exactly what technology means to man, questions about where the lines are drawn, if any can be, between mimicking and recreating human emotions… questions about the future. In one interesting, small piece of dialogue while Frank and Dave discuss the option of disconnecting HAL, Dave says, “Well, I’m not so sure what he’d think of it.” Neither are we, but the line suggests that “at some emotional level, [he] cares about HAL’s existence” (Nofz 40). Perhaps that is all man can be expected to do -- care about, if not fully comprehend -- the existence and purpose of technology.

Thursday, November 02, 2006

Unraveling the Detective Myth in Film Noir

This is the second post of a multi-post sequence in which I copy and paste old college papers so that my blog can claim to have more intelligent writing in it. Please revel in the genius. Please...

In earlier fiction, the detective has always been a near mythological character, possessing incredible powers of insight, profound ingenuity, and deductive reasoning. His brains are almost superhuman in the way they are fully able to grasp the universe completely. The classic example of this is Sherlock Holmes, the sure and able protector of the community, possessing a sense of calm confidence, even when things seem too confusing to make sense. His passion for proof and truth allows him to notice details as he reads signs objectively and from afar, decoding the cryptic situation until everything becomes obvious for the reader; yet, throughout, it seems that everything has been obvious to him all along. He goes through his job with aplomb because he just knows that everything in the world is knowable. However, as the upheaval of the first half of the twentieth century came to a head, with a depression and two world wars, this myth began to unravel into something much more complex and human, and is embodied in what has become known as film noir -- stories about detectives that are marked not by confidence in the world, but by the two major themes of the limits of the knowable and male paranoia/anxiety. As the upheaval of the second half of the century burst, with the Cold War and political and social strife, the detective myth unraveled even further, additionally expressing the limits of the doable. The classic film noir The Maltese Falcon and the neo-noir Chinatown illustrate this point perfectly. While they share these themes in a syntactic sense, however, they do differ semantically in the way these themes are addressed.

Critics often call The Maltese Falcon the first film noir. Written and directed by John Huston before World War II, it exists as one of the more optimistic examples of the genre, although I use that adjective in a completely relative sense. On the surface, the film is about tough, hard-boiled private detective Samuel Spade, who, after the murder of his partner Miles Archer, becomes embroiled in a convoluted plot involving all sorts of criminals, low-lifes, and antique dealers, to secure an extremely valuable and historically mystical and elusive statuette of a falcon. However, taken as a whole, the film is an expression of epistemological uncertainty and male paranoia.

When it comes to the first theme of what is knowable, Spade is no Holmes, nor is the world he moves through the world Holmes moves through. Spade does not -- can not -- solve the mystery by looking at solid clues and physical evidence, trusting in logic and deduction with the certainty of a classic detective, because the world around him is neither solid nor logical. Instead, he must delve right into the shady underworld of the criminal, nearly becoming one himself as he becomes at odds with both the police and the scoundrels in trying to dig up the truth (a true spade, indeed). In becoming so embroiled, rather than maintaining the clinically intellectual objectivity and distance of a Holmes, he in a way admits that everything he concludes can only be his own interpretation, and that this unavoidable subjectivity par involvement, this inability to observe objectively, leaves true holes of mystery that the detective can never be capable of filling in for the audience. Spade is not completely lost in such a world, of course, as he seems to wheel and deal separately with the police and the criminals Brigid O’Shaughnessy, Joel Cairo, Wilmer Cook, and Casper Gutman with a measure of capability. However, the now distinctive technique of low-key lighting almost constantly shrouds Spade’s world in shadow, hiding what truths we may never know. A colleague warns Spade, “You think you always know what you’re doing, but you’re too slick for your own good,” a warning highlighted by the numerous name changes, false identities, lies, and double-crosses he must try to navigate, and not always deftly. Spade is a detective vulnerable and human enough to be drugged by Gutman and to be duped, at least for a while, into falling for O’Shaughnessy. Something like that would never happen to Holmes; indeed, Spade’s world is much more chaotic, and thus difficult to discern. When Cairo and O’Shaughnessy discuss the falcon in front of Spade in his home, revealing their unforeseen familiarity and throwing Spade and the audience for a loop, there is a quick shot of Spade’s shocked face, with a completely dark and shadowed wall behind him -- the ominous and unknowable shadows of the world have even managed to creep into Spade’s own home! Later, Spade explains to Cairo that a “sensible story” told to the police would have landed them in jail; it is a ludicrous story that passes for truth in this world. When Gutman makes a toast to “clear understanding and plain speaking,” the double-crosses only increase. In trying to price the falcon, he says, “There’s no telling how high it could go. That’s the one and only truth about it.” It’s telling that the one and only truth is that nobody knows, and this is a theme in general, not just about the falcon’s worth. Throughout the film, a man named Floyd Thursby is talked about a lot, someone we never even meet or see. In the end, the statuette everyone was clambering for turns out to be fake, and the whereabouts of the real statue remain a mystery. He calls the fake one “the stuff that dreams are made of,” expressing the futility and ethereality of even a hard, solid, physical clue. All these things sum up to indicate an uncertain and unknowable world.

The second theme of male anxiety is also very prominent. The film is composed almost entirely of either interior shots, which create a claustrophobic feeling enhanced by the many shadows, or exterior nighttime shots, marked by ominous darkness -- both point to a certain level of anxiety. When the police accuse Spade of killing Thursby, there is a shot of him in the middle of the frame, an officer towering over him to his left, and another sitting lower than him to his right, thus threateningly trapping Spade in the middle. Of course, the ultimate symbol of male paranoia is his antithesis, the femme fatale, O’Shaughnessy in this film. Spade is constantly watchful of her as she changes names, lies, double-crosses, and eventually admits to killing Archer. Her presence establishes the tradition in film noir that women can’t be trusted, especially rich, beautiful, seductive, and/or helpless ones, and the many scenes with her highlight this point. She never quits what Spade calls her “school-girl act,” yet her affectation of helplessness is often undermined by the way she is filmed. One shot has her standing ominously over a sitting Spade as the window blinds behind her either pierce her with ill-omened lines of death or suggest her criminality as prison bars. Another shot shows the shadows created by the blinds slanting diagonally across the wall, right behind Spade, off-angle lines that destabilize the frame, and menace to destabilize Spade. Her whole hotel room, in fact, is marked by the blinds and striped chairs, a light-dark-light-dark pattern that certainly suggests her duality, and adds to Spade’s male paranoia. Spade, moreover, is constantly rolling his own cigarettes, in an almost ritualistic fashion, ritual being a common male answer to anxiety; additionally, if one sees the cigarette as a phallic symbol, this cigarette rolling can thus be understood as a way of affirming his maleness in the face of the femme fatale threat.

However, Spade is ultimately able to hand in all the criminals and save his own neck, an astonishing feat given all the uncertainty that surrounds him; and although he comes close to falling for O’Shaughnessy’s wiles, he is sensible enough to pragmatically weigh the pros and cons of running away with this dangerous woman, and decides to turn her in. Thus, initially, film noir as a genre dealt with conquerable limits of knowledge, and preventable anxiety. Unfortunately for the private detective, these themes spiraled out of control in revisionist neo-noir films like Roman Polanski’s Chinatown that reread the genre with an even more cynical attitude towards the world.

The plot of Chinatown is even more convoluted than The Maltese Falcon’s, with private detective Jake Gittes starting off spying on supposedly cheating husband Hollis Mulray for a woman who pretends to be suspicious wife Evelyn, and ending with a gigantic, fantastically lucrative water-diversion plot by her the real Evelyn’s father Noah Cross, in which a totally unforeseen incestuous relationship is revealed. In this brief description, one can already begin to see the two themes of epistemological limits and male paranoia emerging.

The structure of the narrative alone addresses the limits of the knowable simply by its convolution and sheer complexity. Every other scene seems to be a plot-point that twists the story in a new direction, and spins Gittes’ head around. He is not nearly as capable as Spade in navigating the labyrinth and discerning truth from falsehood, but it is also a more labyrinthine world Gittes must operate in. A woman pretending to be Mrs. Mulray easily dupes him into spying on Mr. Mulray, making Gittes look like quite a fool. It looks like Mr. Mulray is actually the bad guy at first, and Cross a good guy. Rather than get drugged like Spade, Gittes has his blackout spell when he gets knocked unconscious by angry farmers. When he snoops around enough to gather the key fact that water is mysteriously being diverted and dumped into the ocean in the middle of a big drought, he almost loses his nose (every bit of knowledge comes at a dear price in this world of uncertainty). Like Spade, Gittes, is told by Cross, “You may think you know what you’re dealing with -- but believe me, you don’t.” Just when Gittes and the audience think they have it all neatly figured out, that Evelyn drowned Hollis in the salt water pool in the backyard, based on salt water in his lungs and his glasses found in the pool, Gittes discovers the limits of what he thinks he knows, when the incestuous relationship of Evelyn and Cross is revealed, and that Mulray never wore bifocals -- but this information comes too late, and Gittes tries but fails to save the innocent and bring down the bad guy, instead helping to kill Evelyn and allowing Cross to escape with the big money-plot and the child of incest. (As an aside, the incest theme is interesting because Cross is played by John Huston, the aforementioned writer-director of the first film noir The Maltese Falcon, and so the “father” of film noir. The mere casting of him in Chinatown is thus a form of genre-incest.) Rather than create uncertainty through lighting and shadows, however, the film uses a different set of semantics, mainly ocular/vision/glass and water/drought motifs. Photos deceive the mind. The fish Cross serves Gittes has a glossed eye, representing a clouded vision that can never see the whole picture. Similarly, Evelyn has a flaw in her iris, another sign of flawed vision. Gittes finds broken bifocals at the bottom of the pool, shattered pieces of glass that reflect a duplicitous and fractured world. Evelyn in the end is shot through her eye, a powerful statement on the seen versus unseen. The dryness of the earth caused by the drought suggests a dried up world with little information to offer. When water/information does arrive, it comes in chaotic deluges that almost drown Gittes, not help him. Water is naturally a more destabilized form of matter that flows and crashes with sometimes unstoppable turmoil, and its presence dominates, perhaps even precludes, more “solid” matter. While Spade’s world of shadows could always be conquered by turning on the light, Gittes’ world of water is wilder, nearly drowning him, and never staying still. Thus, it is the imperfect vision and unmanageable water together that suggest, with different semantics, the same syntax as The Maltese Falcon, that the world is not just uncertain, but unknowable.

Male paranoia is also not only present, but severely heightened in the film. As a neo-noir, the audience must instantly suspect the rich, beautiful woman that walks into the office, the femme fatale that poses such a threat to the male psyche, and indeed, Ida Sessions was fooling Gittes. But the great trick that Polanski pulls on us film noir scholars is to set up Evelyn as the femme fatale, where she shows a willingness to play Gittes’ game against the police by lying to them (a similar event happens in The Maltese Falcon), where Gittes handles her lying during a dinner scene, and where he apparently establishes her guilt in a murder, only to knock us all back by revealing that she wasn’t a femme fatale at all, but an innocent victim of incest trying to protect her sister-daughter. He thus toys with the idea of the femme fatale in such a way that it only increases any male paranoia towards women. Whereas before, we could have counted on the woman being evil, now, after Chinatown, who knows? The uncertainty merely aggravates the anxiety. Gittes also can’t affirm his maleness by rolling his own cigarettes; he smokes pre-rolled ones from a case. In fact, the most prominent phallic symbol in this film isn’t an affirmation à la Spade, but something that literally goes under the knife. Gittes walks around half the movie with an awkwardly large white bandage on his nose, because of a knife-cut he gets from a hotheaded gangster. It is interesting that just when he begins to start snooping around and sticking his nose into the darkness, he gets it cut, a sign that the world is so dangerous that it will unman you, even castrate you, if one reads the nose as a phallic symbol. No doubt such a threat would unnerve any man; since castration is a reality, male anxiety and paranoia are brought to their highest possible intensity. Nobody ever went around chopping Spade’s cigarettes with a knife.

The element of castration also adds to a third additional theme of the limits of the doable. Not only can Gittes not really know anything, he can’t really do anything either, as exemplified by the ending of the film and the symbol of Chinatown; in other words, Gittes is impotent, his actions meaningless. He was advised to do “as little as possible” as a cop in Chinatown, and he mutters this phrase as he realizes that his earnest but bungling efforts to save Evelyn only led to her death. As if that wasn’t dark enough, the film suggests that the events are part of an inescapable cycle of karma-like fate. It is revealed that in the shadows of his past, Gittes was somehow responsible for the death of a woman he perhaps loved while he was a cop in Chinatown, which was why he left to become a private detective. At the end of the film, things somehow devolve for Gittes back to Chinatown where another woman that he perhaps loves is killed because of him. It seems that he simply cannot escape this terrible destiny, and it is this point that gives the film its nihilistic drive. As the movie ends, his partner tells him, “Forget it, Jake. It’s Chinatown,” underscoring the inefficacy and impotence in trying to do anything in this world. There is simply nothing Gittes can do; he is powerless against the chaos. To further hammer home this cynicism, Cross is not condemned to a futile pursuit of the dubious “stuff dreams are made of,” as is implied for his counterpart Gutman at the end of The Maltese Falcon. Rather, Cross’ desire is for something else that shares a similar intangible and ethereal quality: the future. And he gets it. A simple glance at a modern map of southern California shows that his plan of bringing L.A. to the valley worked, earning him untold millions. Nobody stops him; he owns the police. Indeed, it seems that in this world of meaningless actions and unknowable uncertainties, money and power are the only things that mean anything -- and so, they mean everything -- in this world. There is nothing like honor that survives here, the way it does in Spade’s world when he is able to avenge his partner’s death, because it’s what you’re “supposed to do.” Instead, you’re supposed to do nothing. With that kind of message, Sherlock Holmes becomes in effect dead.

Thus, film noir, expressing epistemological uncertainty and male paranoia, is a genre that reflects a twentieth-century take on the old detective myth, unraveling it at first with The Maltese Falcon, and eventually killing it completely in Chinatown. Black film, indeed.

Sunday, October 29, 2006

Milton's Pride and Humility

This is the first in a multi-part series in which I post past college papers I've written on this blog, because I have nothing creative or new to offer, yet I want to show off how insightful and articulate I am. This particular paper comes from freshman year, so it has its flaws. But at the heart of it, the thesis is a pretty profound understanding of the epic poem. Please don't be alarmed by my genius.

Paradise Lost can be loosely divided into two distinct halves, Books I through VI and Books VII through XII. The first half deals predominantly with the way things were before God created Earth, before the Biblical “six days.” Although Adam, Eve, Eden, and Earth do appear in the first half, they are used primarily as a forum in which Michael can relate to Adam the pre-Earth history of the Universe, i.e. Satan’s rebellion against God, his banishment to Hell, and his subsequent plans, although not in that order. Conversely, the second half of the poem deals almost exclusively with the real action that transpires on Earth, starting with the “six days,” Adam’s recollections of first becoming ontologically aware, and, of course, the tempting of Eve by Satan, man’s subsequent fall and banishment from Paradise, and even, in prophetic vision, Cain and Abel, Noah’s Ark, and Jesus Christ.

Each of these halves has a corresponding invocation in which Milton asks for divine inspiration, and each half has a distinct tone which fittingly introduces its subject matter. In short, the pre-Earth invocation uses very ambitious, boastful, and proud language, announcing its attempt to reach above and beyond our Universe, perhaps appropriate since this half of the book will concern itself exactly with such things that are above and beyond our Universe; the post-Earth invocation, on the other hand, uses language that is more grounded, humble, and, if I may say, “down to earth” than its forerunner, also perhaps appropriate, given that the text concerns itself with events that take place on Earth. However, at the same time, Milton also concedes that he does require some divine aid to reach his ambitious heights in the first invocation, while declaring in the second invocation that he won’t need much more help now that he has his feet on firm, familiar ground, so to speak.

The first invocation in Book I begins audaciously, asserting Milton as a cut above precursors like Homer and Virgil. It declares its subject matter to be “Of man’s first disobedience” (1.1). The word “first” can be construed not only in a chronological sense, but also as first in importance. The entire premise of using an invocation is obviously an homage to past epic writers like Homer and Virgil, but Milton also uses the invocation as a form to elevate himself and his poem above his predecessors. Within the same paradigm that they used, he declares his work “first” on the list, above whatever smaller, pettier stories Homer and Virgil had to tell about Odysseus or Aeneas. There is no doubt that Milton adopts a very proud attitude in this regard. Furthering his tone of unabashed superiority over the Classical era, he invokes the “aid” of his Muse, the Holy Spirit (in contrast to the lesser pagan Muses of mythology), to, “with no middle flight… soar above th’ Aonian mount” (1.13-5). Unlike Homer, who’s Muse is actually the one telling the story through him as a simple medium, Milton merely asks for “aid” so that he himself may “soar.” Milton, in this way, takes more ownership, more credit, for what he’s about to write than was traditionally done before him. His statements about wanting to bypass the “middle flight” and go above the “Aonian mount” are both allusions to places in which Greek inspiration resided. Milton, therefore, will go beyond whatever mental plane Greek writers aspired to, to something greater, grander, and closer to God and Heaven. The word “soar” itself is an interesting choice as well; it invokes an image of an angel with God-given wings reaching heights that no other bird of the earth can. It is an image about as ambitious as an image can get without drawing parallels between Milton and God Himself. Finally, his claim that his poem “pursues things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme” is a further insult to Classical writers (1.15-6). The implication is that they were never Godly enough, they were never good enough, to even think to attempt something on Milton’s ambitiously grandiose scale. They were only able to attempt stories of much less significance, and much less purpose. Milton’s words are wracked with pride and boastfulness.

Besides raising his relative worth in comparison with preceding epic writers (or lowering theirs, whichever your perspective), he also, in a subtle way, implies the cleanliness of his own personal moral character. He claims that the Spirit that he is trying to contact prefers to speak to “th’ upright heart and pure” (1.18). Our right hand tells us that this Spirit definitely made good and answered Milton’s requests, or else we wouldn’t have a poem to read. The implication, then, is that Milton is indeed upright and pure, deemed worthy by the Spirit to communicate this message, and Milton is not afraid to boast about it.

Milton closes his invocation with more elevation of his subject matter, as can be seen in the following lines to the Spirit:

“Instruct me, for thou know’st; thou from the first

Wast present, and with mighty wings outspread

Dove-like sat’st brooding on the vast abyss

And mad’st it pregnant…” (1.19-22).

The footnote for this passage says that Milton is emphasizing “the creative power and wisdom needed for such great undertakings as creating the world and writing this definitive poem” (Elledge 8). Equating the omnipotent forces that created the known Universe with the inspiration for this one poem seems rather ridiculous. It indicates just how weighty and profound Milton sees his own work, a rather brazen and pretentious way to approach things, especially at the outset. It’s fine to be proud, but to equate a poem with all of Creation?

Finally, the last two lines of the invocation really don’t need that much elaboration. Forgetting the Spirit’s role in the matter, he says, “I may assert Eternal Providence, and justify the ways of God to men” (1.25-6). In using first person, he assumes the full responsibility for this substantial charge. The tone of the phrase “assert Eternal Providence,” makes Milton appear rather presumptuous and pompous; who is he to assert to the rest of mankind anything, let alone something as weighty as Eternal Providence? Furthermore, that he wishes to “justify the ways of God to men” shows that he sees “men” as lesser than him, unable to understand God’s justice, and therefore it is up to the more Godly, more intelligent Milton to explain to all the uncomprehending souls exactly what God means. This is arrogance at its most complete, tempered only by his implicit admission that he can’t do it alone, and that he does need divine “aid,” although Milton seems to shoulder a preponderance of the responsibility and the credit when it comes to this charge. Milton can also be seen in a better light if we recognize that it was perhaps Milton’s intention to sound that boastful to introduce the first half of the poem, as a way of recognizing that this part of the story will mostly concern itself with things happening beyond Earth, in Heaven and Hell. Regardless of his reasons, however, Milton’s language in this invocation is undeniably marked by boastfulness, pride, and ambition.

The second invocation in Book VII is marked by a slight tonal shift, conveyed by Milton’s concession that perhaps he did not belong in Heaven, where the first half of the book often ventured. While the general theme in the first invocation was one of soaring ascension to great heights, the first word of this second invocation asks Milton’s Muse to “Descend from heav’n…” (7.1). Instead of riding on her wings upward, he’s now asking her to come down to him, admitting that he can’t write from up on high anymore. This shows a more humble, self-abnegating Milton, who is willing to suggest that his place is still on Earth, among the rest of the mortals. He is now “down to earth” in more ways than one. Milton also characterizes his stay on a divinely inspired plane as being “an earthly guest” (7.14). In this line, he both continues to ground himself as being merely “earthly,” while humbling himself, appropriately, as simply a guest in Heaven.

Milton even goes so far as to say that while his inspiration was ascending towards Heaven in the first half of the poem, he needed his Muse’s “temp’ring” of the “empyreal air” to survive, meaning the air up there was not suitable for mortal lungs (7.14-5). The implication is that Milton was plainly not built of Heavenly material; in a very basic, profound way, his constitution simply was not made for the heights he had so brazenly aspired to in the first invocation. He is deconstructing his previous arrogance and realigning himself with the rest of man, for ultimately, he recognizes that he is just a man. In fact, he expresses reservations, or even fear, about having been so high up; he wants to “return to [his] native element” before he falls “erroneous… to wander and forlorn” in a plane of mental existence beyond what was meant for him, or any man (7.16-20). He concedes that Earth, his “native element” is where he belongs, where it is safe, where he can not and will not “fall erroneous.” The next few lines in the text fairly explicitly express this sentiment:

“Half yet remains unsung, but narrower bound

Within the visible diurnal sphere;

Standing on earth, not rapt above the pole,

More safe I sing with mortal voice…” (7.21-4).

These lines also suggest the aforementioned possibility that Milton wrote each invocation to match the subject matter of the different halves of the poem. He says that the “half” that “remains unsung” is “narrower bound within the visible diurnal sphere,” basically meaning that the second half of the epic deals with the Universe that man knows about, i.e. the Earth and the stars. Correspondingly, he asks to get off the wildly flying horse of inspiration, Pegasus, to more appropriately address the rest of his story. He wants to use a “mortal” voice to speak now, more comfortable to be “standing on earth” than “rapt above the pole” (transported above the Universe). All of these things show a more grounded and humble Milton than in the previous invocation.

In the last lines of this passage, he even expresses this concern: “So fail not thou, who thee implores” (7.38). Aside from the self-effacement inherent in the fact that he uses the word “implores” to describe the nature of his requests, Milton also recognizes the possibility of failure. If his Muse leaves him, he will fail. This is not the Milton from Book I, to whom the chance of failure never occurred. This Milton knows he is fallible; there are no claims of being “upright” and “pure.” This is as much humility as we can reasonably expect from a man of such self-righteous Puritanism. Of course, implicit in his descent back to Earth is the likelihood that he still believes he is the best to ever write among men. The phrase “my native element” can be seen as a way of staking out his claim: the Earth belongs to him. He may not be worthy of Heaven, but he is a master of Earth. Milton’s getting off the “Pegasean wing” of inspiration can be construed to mean that he doesn’t need it anymore. He can handle himself now. In effect, he has done this to regain control, to regain mastery of his domain. Consequentially, his newfound humility is possibly shadowed by his regained confidence, self-assurance, and daresay pride on returning to Earth. This is just conjecture of course; in reading only for definitive evidence, Milton’s language in the second invocation ultimately seems to have humbled itself for the second half of the poem, to match the Earth-bound subject matter to follow, i.e. Creation, Adam and Eve, and the Fall.

When all’s said and done, Milton’s genius can not be disputed. His work indeed is an extraordinary feat of the English language, written in an English of the highest order. It was indeed something that had never quite been attempted in that way before, and most likely never again. So whether he was humble or proud, or both, is ultimately, perhaps, immaterial. Either way, Milton probably was justified – nay, he deserved – to feel anything he wished to feel. His was indeed a God-like genius.

Thursday, February 03, 2005

Responsibility, Power, and the President

In recognition of George W. Bush's State of the Union Address last night, here's a paper I wrote two years ago.

RESPONSIBILITY, POWER, AND THE PRESIDENT
By D.X. Liu
Introduction

Most will agree that the office of President of the United States of America is something in-between useless figurehead and omnipotent totalitarian. The distinction that must be drawn before assessing the amount of control the President has against the amount of responsibility attributed to that office is one of actual power versus mere influence. It is the position of this paper that the public generally holds the President decidedly responsible for both foreign affairs and the economy; while the President does receive due credit or opprobrium in foreign affairs per his* real power in that arena, he receives undue credit or opprobrium for the economy, his control over that field being limited to only oblique influence.

Presidential scholars suggest that the public has come to believe that "the man inside the White House" can do "something about everything."[1] American presidents "must partake in a presidency where actual powers of the institution do not meet the expectations and the responsibilities that many citizens have for the office."[2] Yet these expectations are often excessive and contradictory; the high expectations of the public for what should be done by a president, weighed against the low expectations for what can be done, always tends to push the probability of failure toward 100 percent.[3] This is what is called the "expectations gap," a phenomenon of public inconsistency that has had a negative impact on the modern presidency.[4] Thus established, the President will always carry great responsibility, as defined by general public perception, in both foreign affairs and the economy; it is the actual power that he has in these realms that determines the aptness of all the credit or opprobrium he may garner for its events.

*Throughout, owing to the deficiency of the English language, the male gender is justified historically but not prospectively when referring to a President, in order to avoid awkwardness of style. He, him, and his are not intended as exclusively masculine pronouns—they may refer to either sex or to both sexes.

Foreign Affairs

There is little in the Constitution that encourages presidential dominance of the foreign policy-making system.[5] Besides being commander-in-chief of all armed forces, constitutionally, the President has little power beyond the realm of diplomatic dialogue with foreign governments; when it comes to concrete issues like treaties, wars, and financial initiatives required for almost any executive action, it is Congress that wields the most power and the most responsibility.[6]

The State Department states that the Constitution creates different and important roles for the President and Congress in the making of foreign policy. The president makes foreign policy through: responses to foreign events, proposals for legislation, negotiation of international agreements, policy statements, policy implementation, and independent action.[7] Congress makes foreign policy through: resolutions and policy statements, legislative directives, legislative pressure, legislative restrictions/funding denials, informal advice, and congressional oversight.[8] This division of foreign policy powers creates a complex, unresolved relationship between the two branches that often overlaps and makes ambiguous who originates or finally determines foreign policy.[9]

In addition, "the roles and relative influence of the two branches in making foreign policy differ from time to time according to such factors as the personalities of the President and Members of Congress and the degree of consensus on policy."[10] Historically, then, scholars have cited "the period 1789-1829 as one of Presidential initiative; 1829-1898 as one of congressional supremacy, and 1899 through the immediate post World War II period as one of growing Presidential power."[11] The most recent period of congressional dominance of foreign policy began toward the end of the Vietnam War, only to have the pendulum swing back toward presidential dominance during the Reagan and Bush, Sr. Administrations, peaking once during Operation Desert Storm in Iraq,[12] and now at a peak again in the aftermath of September 11 and in the rumblings of another war with Iraq.

Thus, despite the President's seemingly meager supervisory role in the Constitution, responsibility and initiative in foreign affairs has naturally devolved on the President, because in matters of crisis or emergency, "Congress was too slow and contrary and the Supreme Court was bound by its procedures."[13] John F. Kennedy defined the President's responsibilities in foreign policy during his campaign in a speech on February 12, 1960. The speech centered around four "facts" that establish the President as the lone power in foreign affairs: his responsibility cannot be delegated, his responsibility cannot be abdicated to Congress, he is responsible to all the people, and he is responsible to the Free World.[14]

It is now generally accepted that the President, and the executive office in general, dominates United States foreign affairs[15], that while American foreign policy is a "divided power," the "lion's share" falls usually to the President.[16] Even during times of peace, foreign policy has been uniquely important to the President; it is the arena that offers presidents "the greatest freedom to exercise their power and the best opportunity to affect policy personally. Important foreign affairs decisions often have been made by the president alone or during intimate consultations with a few trusted advisors."[17] Today, the President is the "chief U.S. foreign policy-maker and national security manager."[18]

Some argue that this is due to the realities of the international system. In foreign affairs, "policy takes precedence over politics because the international system both severely limits the sensible choices a country can make and shapes the processes by which these decisions are reached."[19] Thus, the international system is relatively free of politics and partisanship and of quibbling with Congress. The foreign policy president enjoys independence, respect, and prestige that enable him to manage foreign affairs quite autonomously from domestic issues.[20]

The are four main differences between domestic and foreign policy that basically elevate the President to virtual omnipotence and relegate Congress to a position of "self-denying ordinance" in which they believe it is not part of their job to determine the nation's foreign policies: first, foreign policy often requires "fast action" that is more appropriate for executive than legislative decision-making; second, the President has far more power to commit resources and obtain information about foreign affairs; third, voters who know little about foreign policy "expect the president to act in foreign affairs" and will "reward him with their confidence" at the polls; and fourth, the interest group structure is weak, unstable, and thin with regard to foreign policy questions.[21] Thus, "to respond to external threats, the United States needs a relatively centralized, coordinated foreign policy-making system."[22]

This environment has allowed for what some term "the two presidencies," in which presidents can act abroad independently of domestic political issues.[23] The Two Presidency Theory supports the reality that the fundamental responsibility for conducting the nation's foreign policy remains in the hands of the President, operating independently of domestic politics; thus, Jimmy Carter could negotiate the SALT II agreement, reverse the policy of détente with the Soviet Union, cancel participation in the Olympics, impose a grain embargo, institute major increases in defense expenditures, facilitate Camp David, and attempt to rescue and finally negotiate the release of U.S. hostages in Iran, without getting re-elected; Ronald Reagan could continue defense build-up and negotiate the START and INF arms agreements while getting re-elected; and George Bush, Sr. could invade Panama, claim the democratization of Eastern Europe, oversee the collapse of the Soviet empire, end the Cold War, negotiate a new arms control agreement with Russia, arrange the first international peace conference in the Middle East, help settle conflicts in Cambodia and South Africa, and wage the Gulf War, without getting re-elected.[24]

However, others argue that the President is always subject to domestic politics, and that his power and his choices in the realm of foreign affairs are constantly affected by Congress and partisanship. There has historically been "a cycle or rhythm" in foreign policy-making, "fluctuating between presidential and congressional ascendance."[25] When Congress and the President are of different parties, two things can happen to foreign policy. If there is a strong difference of opinion, a paralysis can occur in American influence in foreign affairs, such as with Woodrow Wilson, a situation that eventually led to an isolationist foreign policy.[26] If the issue is important enough for the president to pursue bi-partisanship, the President will find himself at a disadvantage in negotiations with powerful senators, such as the situation with Harry S Truman and Senator Vandenburg, the Republican Chairman of the Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs.[27] The President is truly the master of foreign policy only if he is in unquestionable control of his party, and his party has the majority in Congress, especially in the Senate.[28]

In light of these requirements, then, one could say that George W. Bush indeed has full mastery of foreign affairs right now, and therefore should definitely take most if not all credit or opprobrium for the coming developments abroad. The theory alluded to earlier that presidential power in foreign affairs increases in times of crisis also applies now, even a year and a half after September 11. Thus all signs say that Bush has more power in foreign affairs today than perhaps any president in the history of the United States. Yet during his campaign in 2000, Bush felt that the President is responsible merely for sketching a vague "big picture" in foreign policy and that he has plenty of advisors to "fill in the details,"[29] a political move, perhaps, to justify his oft-publicized lack of knowledge about foreign leaders and events at the time. Despite this, Bush has been seen as having taken the reins after September 11; Congress tried to play a role in specific foreign policy response in a report dated September 12, 2001, particularly highlighting "radical Islamic fundamentalist groups" as posing a major terrorist threat to U.S. interests, and outlining particular policy tools to be used against them.[30] However, two days later, Congress basically authorized full discretion by Bush in response to the attacks, stating that "the President is authorized to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any further acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations or persons."[31] Indeed, with such deference by Congress, the President today should be held responsible for foreign affairs, if he is to possess so much power.

The Economy

In contrast, the Constitution grants the President even less specific powers over the economy. The framers "clearly intended Congress to be the branch of government most concerned with the economic affairs of the nation," giving it, among other things, the power to: levy and collect taxes, duties, imposts and excises, pay debts, borrow money, regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the states, coin money and regulate its value, and regulate the value of foreign currency.[32]

While presidents understood that promoting the nation's prosperity was important to their job, attempts to affect the actual performance of the economy through spending and taxing decisions per the theories of John Maynard Keynes didn't come until Franklin Delano Roosevelt's unprecedented New Deal government expenditures during the Great Depression of the 1930s,[33] and weren't universally accepted as part of presidential responsibility until Kennedy's landmark tax cuts in 1962. It was there that the "argument for fiscal management was won."[34]

However, such new presidential responsibility may have left an infuriating legacy for the likes of Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter, and George Bush, Sr., who shared the fate of Martin Van Buren and Herbert Hoover before them as presidents who were punished by voters for economic downturns during election years.[35] The fact of the matter is, with regards to the economy, the President will always be trapped in a "power gap" in which he has "important but severely limited" legal and administrative means to influence the economy's health and growth.[36] Despite high expectations of the American public and the President's primary role in economic policy-making, "the president's ability to influence economic conditions does not measure up to presidential responsibility for them."[37] Indeed, sitting in the center of the economic complex, they are expected to maintain prosperity and are criticized if it declines, even though what they can do about it is "hardly more than peripheral," more correctly called influence than power.[38] Economic experts also generally agree that the division of government with the most real power over the economy is the Federal Reserve Board, whose monetary powers of control are independent of the executive; while the Chairman of the Fed is often appointed by the President, he is by design not responsible to him.[39]

Yet presidents must maintain an aura of activity as well, working with the Department of the Treasury, his Council of Economic Advisers, Congress's Office of Management and Budget, and the Federal Reserve Board to constantly tweak taxation, spending, and the money supply in the hopes that if these efforts do not in actuality affect the economy, he will at least be perceived by voters as being concerned and doing the best he can. However, these efforts, scholars suggest, have served to merely perpetuate the "jagged prongs of a predicament" the President is always in, in which his "authority over the economy does not equal his responsibility for its condition."[40] As candidates, future presidents usually overstate and overestimate their ability to improve the economy in order to get elected.[41] It is thus partly their own fault that they are now expected to "steer" the economy, a gross misconception of what the economy is: "it's not a ship," but a figure of speech representing "a bunch of people engaged in production and trade."[42] The illusion of power is on both sides: candidates promise things they cannot control, and voters punish or reward for things that could not be controlled. Thus, as it is said, Americans will often "vote their pocket books," encouraging convoluted politics of fiscal and monetary policy that are "produced through an unwieldy political process of negotiation and compromise between the legislative and executive branches" instead of through sound consideration of "long-term and short-term needs of the country."[43]

So while the President lacks any real power over the economy, he does have several media through which he can at least provide some oblique influence and general guidelines to affect the overall pace of economic activity. The four main areas of influence are in stabilization and growth, regulations and control, direct services, and direct assistance.[44] The goals for stabilization and growth are to "maintain steady growth, high levels of employment, and price stability."[45] The methods of such have differed greatly over the last forty years. In the 1960s, great faith was put into fiscal policy, the manipulation of government revenues to influence the economy.[46] In the 1970s, stagflation killed that dream, and monetary policy grew prominent instead, controlling the nation's money supply through devices such as interest rates.[47] In the 1980s, Reaganomics, or supply-side economics was introduced, based on tax cuts to stimulate production rather than consumption.[48] In the 1990s, taxes slowly crept up again, reducing the budget and creating a surplus. Today, Bush has emulated Reagan's administration, passing a "pro-growth" tax cut in 2001.[49] Regulation and control often involve intensive legislation that the President can initiate. Fighting monopolies, protecting public health and the environment, and promoting competition and technological advancement are all ways the President can try to set general guidelines for the economy, though by no means of course controlling it outright.[50] Direct services run the gamut from defense spending to financing of public schools.[51] Direct assistance can involve low-interest loans, Social Security, and Medicare.[52] All these things were initiated and/or promoted somewhere along the line by American presidents.

Despite misplaced presidential accountability for the economy, this most recent economic downturn doesn't seem to be hurting Bush very much at all. Bush's rhetoric was very positive and optimistic early in his presidency, stating, "We've got a plan to get our economy moving so Americans can find work… I want the American people to know we're deeply concerned about the unemployment rates and we intend to do something about it."[53] And despite the continual fall of the economy since, a poll conducted by Fox News/Opinion Dynamics last year found that "only 5% of Americans say Bush is most responsible for the recession (tied with Bill Clinton and Congress)."[54] The top culprits in the poll were "economic cycles (36%)" and "the September 11 attacks, anthrax scares, and war in Afghanistan (19%),"[55] surprisingly lucid results from a public that is supposed to simply blame or praise presidents for everything. Another poll conducted last year by ABC News/Washington Post also revealed that "55% of voters say Bush bears little or no responsibility for the return of deficit spending in Washington," or the drying up of the federal surplus supposedly caused by the tax cuts early in his term.[56] A Battleground Poll last year showed that voters see Bush (49%) rather than the Democrats (29%) as "better equipped to keep the nation prosperous."[57] Consequently, Republicans swept the mid-term elections and now control both houses of Congress as well as the White House. However, as elections near again, the climate may be changing again. Americans will hold Bush responsible if their prosperity suffers any more, now that the government is firmly in Republican control; "it's Bush's economy now."[58] It will be interesting to see if voters continue to have confidence in the President as the economy continues to suffer; getting into the third and fourth years of a presidency, "it gets harder to escape what happens on your watch."[59] Already the self-perpetuating paradigm of presidential responsibility exceeding presidential power in the economy is being bolstered by Senator John Edwards, a Democratic candidate hopeful for the presidency. Latent in his criticism that Bush's economic plans make "no sense" and in his own proposed plans to jumpstart the sagging economy[60] is the assumption once again that the President has any control at all.

Conclusion

It is probably safe to say that the President of the United States, no matter who he or she is, will always be viewed with a certain mystique by the general public. It is the one person in the entire Constitution who stands out like an archetypal hero of lore, a champion of the people. History has shrouded the office in myth and legend. It is a place where a lone individual can rise up and become great… become immortal. That is why the public will probably always view the presidency with high expectations and high regard. Whether this is fair enough overall, this paper has not examined. But at least with foreign affairs, the President is generally supreme, and credit or opprobrium will generally be due. And unfortunately for him, or maybe even because of him, with the economy, the President is markedly more impotent, and credit or opprobrium will generally be undeserved.

God bless America.



Notes

[1] Neustadt, Richard E. Presidential Power and the Modern Presidents: The Politics of Leadership from Roosevelt to Reagan. New York: Free, 1990. 7.

[2] Orman, John. Presidential Accountability: New and Recurring Problems. Westport: Greenwood, 1990. 144.

[3] Waterman, Richard W., Hank C. Jenkins-Smith, and Carol L. Silva. "The Expectations Gap Thesis: Public Attitudes toward an Incumbent President." The Journal of Politics 61.4 (1999): 945.

[4] Waterman, 946.

[5] Peterson, Paul E. "The President's Dominance in Foreign Policy Making." Political Science Quarterly 109.2 (1994): 220.

[6] Laski, Harold J. "The American President and Foreign Relations." The Journal of Politics 11.1 (1949): 171.

[7] Grimmett, Richard F. "Foreign Policy Roles of the President and Congress." Bureau of Public Affairs. 1 June 1999. U.S. Department of State. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[8] Grimmett.

[9] Grimmett.

[10] Grimmett.

[11] Grimmett.

[12] Grimmett.

[13] Tugwell, Rexford G. "The President and His Helpers: A Review-Article." Political Science Quarterly 82.2 (1967): 260.

[14] Kennedy, John F. "The Leader of the Free World." Address. 12 Feb. 1960. NS News. Newsworld Showdown. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[15] "Foreign Affairs of the United States." Browse Topics. Ed. Michael Van Fossen. 15 Aug. 2001. U of North Carolina, GPO, and Oklahoma State U. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[16] Grimmett.

[17] Diller, Daniel C. "Chief Diplomat." Powers of the Presidency. Eds. Margaret Seawell Benjaminson, Michael Nelson, and John L. Moore. Washington: CQ, 1989. 105.

[18] Orman, 1.

[19] Peterson, 232.

[20] Peterson, 226.

[21] Peterson, 226.

[22] Peterson, 217.

[23] Peterson, 225.

[24] Peterson, 215 – 223.

[25] Koenig, Louis W. The Chief Executive. 5th ed. San Diego: Harcourt, 1986. 203.

[26] Laski, 174.

[27] Laski, 174.

[28] Laski, 174.

[29] Parry, Robert. "Bush Backfire." Fifth Estate. 1999. VOTE.COM. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[30] Perl, Raphael F. "Terrorism, the Future, and U.S. Foreign Policy." Congressional Research Service. 12 September 2001. United States. Cong. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[31] United States. Cong. House. Cong. Rec. 14 Sept. 2001: H5638. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[32] Diller, Daniel C., and Dean J. Peterson. "Chief Economist." Powers of the Presidency. Eds. Margaret Seawell Benjaminson, Michael Nelson, and John L. Moore. Washington: CQ, 1989. 245.

[33] Diller, and Peterson, "Economist," 247.

[34] Tugwell, 258.

[35] Koenig, 254 – 5.

[36] Koenig, 253 – 4.

[37] Diller, and Peterson, "Economist," 245.

[38] Tugwell, 259.

[39] Tugwell, 259.

[40] Koenig, 254.

[41] Diller, and Peterson, "Economist," 245.

[42] Richman, Sheldon. "No One Is Qualified." Freedom Daily. Dec. 2000. The Future of Freedom Foundation. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[43] Diller, "Economist," 259.

[44] "How the U.S. Economy Works." International Information Programs. U.S. Department of State. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[45] "How."

[46] "How."

[47] "How."

[48] Diller, and Peterson, "Economist," 257.

[49] Cheney, Richard. Address, Conservative Political Action Conference. 15 Feb. 2001. Conservative Political Action Conference. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[50] "How."

[51] "How."

[52] "How."

[53] Bush, George W. "President Voices Concern Over Economy." Address, Outside the Oval Office. 7 Sept. 2001. Office of the Press Secretary. White House. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[54] Dunham, Richard S. "A Bum Economy Is No Boost for Dems." BusinessWeek Online 4 Feb. 2002. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[55] Dunham, "Bum."

[56] Dunham, "Bum."

[57] Dunham, "Bum."

[58] Dunham, Richard S. "How Bush Can Lift a Sagging Economy." BusinessWeek Online 6 Jan. 2003. 9 Feb. 2003 .

[59] Dunham, "How."

[60] "President's Economic Plan 'Makes No Sense.'" News from Senator John Edwards. 6 Jan. 2003. U.S. Senate. 9 Feb. 2003 .